A tampon holds one tampon. Revolutionary, we know.
Every "cup vs tampon" article on the internet is arguing about which one you should marry. You're not marrying anything. Day one and day five are different sports, and you're allowed to change kit between them. So: what each one holds, how long it lasts, what it costs and which day it's for. All in regular tampons, because a teaspoon means nothing to anyone at 6am.
The table nobody bothered to make
| Period Cup | Tampon | Period underwear | |
| Holds | Size 1 (Regular): around 3 regular tampons' worth (up to 5 teaspoons). Size 2 (Large): up to 4 regular tampons' worth (up to 6.5 teaspoons) | 1 regular tampon | Super Light: under 1 tampon. Light: around 2. Moderate: around 3. Heavy: around 4 |
| Wear time | Up to 8 hours | Follow the packet, generally 4 to 8 hours | Up to 8 hours depending on style and flow |
| Cost | $22, once | Around $240 a year on tampons and pads | $20 to $26 a pair, lasts around 2 years |
| Reusable | Yes | No | Yes |
| Feels like | Nothing at all, once it's in properly | A tampon | Normal underwear |
| Best day | Heavy days and long days with no bathroom in sight | Whatever is already in the cupboard | Every single day, including the maybe day |
Day one: bring everything
Day one is a volume problem and one tampon is not a volume answer. Size 2 of the Period Cup takes up to 4 regular tampons' worth and gives you up to 8 hours.
Loads of people double up on day one. Cup in, Period Boyshort on (around 4 tampons' worth, the most absorbent pair we make), and the entire morning off from checking. Overkill is a perfectly good strategy on the day you'd otherwise be scheduling your life around a bathroom.
The middle days, when it's merely irritating
Moderate flow is roughly 3 tampons of capacity. Size 1 of the cup, or a Moderate pair like the High-Waist Period Brief.
This is where the cup quietly wins. Eight hours of not thinking about your period costs $22, once. Less than a round of drinks, and it outlasts the hangover by about a decade.
The maybe day
You know the one. Something is happening. Or nothing is. You've checked twice.
A tampon on a maybe day is uncomfortable and wasteful. A cup on a maybe day is a full production for no reason. This is undies territory. Super Light takes under a tampon's worth and Light takes around 2. The Period Invisible Thong is $20 and looks like normal underwear because it is normal underwear with a job.
Swimming, sleeping, and eight hours of meetings
Swimming needs its own kit. Tampons work. Ordinary period undies don't. Period Swim Brief at $42 or Period Swim Short at $46 are built for the water, around a tampon's worth each, so light days and backup.
Sleep wants coverage and a high waist, because gravity has never once been on your team. Boyshort again, obviously. And for the day with six meetings and no bathroom window, the cup is the only one of the three that lasts the whole block without a plan.
What it actually costs you
Around $240 a year on tampons and pads. That's the number people flinch at. A $22 cup plus two or three pairs at $20 to $26 lands under that, once, and the undies last around 2 years. The maths does itself, which is more than a tampon has ever done.
Don't buy the lot in one go. Sort your worst day first, then add the second format when the first one earns it. Cup Starter Set is $27 with the wash, Underwear Starter Set is $62. And read Everything You Need to Know About Period Cups plus How Does Period Underwear Actually Work? before you spend a cent.
Quick answers
Does a period cup hold more than a tampon? Yes. Size 1 holds around 3 regular tampons' worth and Size 2 holds up to 4, for up to 8 hours.
Can you wear period underwear with a cup? Yes, and on heavy days it's the sensible combination. Cup for capacity, undies for backup.
Which is cheapest over a year? Reusables. Around $240 a year on disposables, against a $22 cup and undies that last around 2 years.